Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
Roslyn and Laurence,
Thank you very much for this great experience. I’m happy my feedback has been helpful to you.
Last Saturday, I started working on the verb tense system with my online class. W
Roslyn and Laurence,Thank you very much for this great experience. I’m happy my feedback has been helpful to you.
Last Saturday, I started working on the verb tense system with my online class. We created “I work” and “I’m working.” During the “I work” section, I discovered that my student knew a limited number of adverbs of frequency and didn’t understand the differences between a couple of words. This was surprising to me, but we practiced using them in “I work” sentences, which was very beneficial for her.
I’ll continue supporting her by revisiting the video clips and written materials. Thank you for allowing me access to this course.
As this is my final feedback, I will now complete the course.
I hope many people take this course and learn a lot!
Michiko
Roslyn,Thank you for clarifying my misunderstanding. It’s clear now.
I don’t think I’ve specifically observed how native English speakers use the verb tense system in speech. I
Roslyn,Thank you for clarifying my misunderstanding. It’s clear now.
I don’t think I’ve specifically observed how native English speakers use the verb tense system in speech. I’ll give it a try. (I’ve mainly focused on written English.)
Roslyn,Thank you very much for using specific examples of the S’s sentences and what you might say in class. Those really helped me understand how to deal with the Simple Present.
You wrote,
Roslyn,Thank you very much for using specific examples of the S’s sentences and what you might say in class. Those really helped me understand how to deal with the Simple Present.
You wrote, ‘I did this in French.’ Do you mean you worked on the English verb system with
French speakers?
Roslyn,The example you provided has helped me better understand the use of the Present Simple.
As I often use grammar textbooks in class, I frequently encounter detailed explanations of the rules.
Roslyn,The example you provided has helped me better understand the use of the Present Simple.
As I often use grammar textbooks in class, I frequently encounter detailed explanations of the rules. This may be why I thought about a situation where a student might ask a question about the difference between work, is going to work, and will work. I realize my question is: Should teachers guide students to explore these differences, or is it unnecessary?
For instance, we elicit sentences from students. If a student says, “I go to work by bus. My bus will come at 7:30 tomorrow,” the use of ‘will’ here feels unnecessary because it refers to a bus schedule. We can simply say, “My bus comes at 7:30.”
[If I apply your explanation to this example, the student doesn’t need to complicate the sentence with concepts like past, limited duration, or markers for the future. They only need the bare essentials—the words: “My bus / come / 7:30” becomes “My bus comes at 7:30.” (Am I understanding this correctly?)]
According to Azar’s grammar book, “The simple present is used to express habitual or everyday activities.” Similarly, Swan’s Practical English Usage states, “We can use the simple present to talk about the future… when referring to events that are part of a timetable or a regular schedule.”
Would you say it’s important for students to become aware of these differences, as highlighted in grammar books? Or can we simply wait for opportunities when students bring in examples naturally, allowing us to explore these distinctions in context?
If we work through the verb tense system step by step—work, is going to work, and will work—will students naturally acquire a sense of these differences even if we don’t explicitly emphasize them?
I know you’re busy, so there’s no rush to reply. I’m happy to wait until you have time to share your thoughts.
Thank you for your guidance.
Roslyn,I read your response 5 or 6 times to understand what you said about the Simple Present tense: ‘…it’s like vocabulary… no “past,” no “before now,” a
Roslyn,I read your response 5 or 6 times to understand what you said about the Simple Present tense: ‘…it’s like vocabulary… no “past,” no “before now,” and no “limitations in time.’ I think I understand it, although perhaps only vaguely for now. I guess that’s why this tense is used for statements like ‘The earth is round.’
As a result of taking this course, I decided to focus on the verb tense system in my class and have already started preparing for it. This course guided me in learning how to help students step by steAs a result of taking this course, I decided to focus on the verb tense system in my class and have already started preparing for it. This course guided me in learning how to help students step by step and view the class from both the teacher’s and the students’ perspectives. This approach encouraged me to try it out in my teaching.I believe it is effective to work on each tense first, having students practice providing triggers and other scaffolding before moving on to the next tense. Once this stage is complete, students are encouraged to talk about various topics using any tense appropriate to the context. Gradually, as their understanding deepens, the triggers and scaffolding are removed, allowing students to construct sentences independently and confidently.
Regarding the structure of this course, I particularly enjoyed and learned from the talks by Roslyn and Laurence. The focused scope—covering just a few key topics—was appropriate and not overwhelming. The actual class video clips were incredibly helpful, as they allowed me to see both the students’ and the teacher’s perspectives. I watched the clips multiple times for this reason.
Exchanging comments in the post section was also beneficial, as it provided opportunities to ask questions, seek clarification, and share my thoughts. The responses from Roslyn and Laurence demonstrated a deep understanding of my concerns and curiosities, which I truly appreciated.
By the end of the course, I felt I wanted to immerse myself in this world even further.
I originally took this course many years ago in a face-to-face setting. Back then, I wanted to implement what I had learned but faced numerous questions about how to guide students and about the tense system itself. These unresolved concerns prevented me from taking action. At the time, I wished the sessions had been videotaped and made available for review.
Now, with this online course, we can revisit the material as often as needed. I’m certain that as my class progresses, I will want to re-watch the videos that align with the situations I encounter in my teaching to seek further guidance. However, I do wonder how long participants are allowed access to the course after completing it… or would you say, “Be independent and find your own way!” 😊
I truly appreciate having had this great experience and am glad I volunteered to take part. Thank you very much!
P.S. If you have certain questions about my feedback and what I have learned from the course, please feel free to ask me.
11 December 2024 at 12:29 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – things to think about as you work #3978Some more thoughts about triggers‘Teaching without rules’
I clicked the link, but it led to an “Oops” page.
Students need an emotional connection
Some more thoughts about triggers‘Teaching without rules’
I clicked the link, but it led to an “Oops” page.
Students need an emotional connection to what they say.
I totally agree with this idea based on my experiences. True stories and the emotions attached to them are key to learning, no matter what the target is.
More about the modals
It’s very interesting to view modals through gestures. I realized that I already use some gestures when working on modals with students, but I wasn’t aware that gestures could become such effective tools for helping students understand the moods within us.
As Roslyn mentioned, covering both exaggerated gestures and more subtle ones is important.
The four-stage model of learning
As a wrap-up, reviewing what has been covered in the course through the four stages would help participants understand the content better, I thought.
Laurence,I understand your point. Thank you for your response.
With the new or detailed information students share with you, “we have to backtrack through their sentence and recast it us
Laurence,I understand your point. Thank you for your response.
With the new or detailed information students share with you, “we have to backtrack through their sentence and recast it using a different tense from where we started.”
I’ve seen examples of this in the videos. I thought that by doing this, students would be able to express themselves more accurately about what they want to say. I’m sure this would help them feel more confident and satisfied. Also, by doing this, they may find answers to their questions, such as the one I mentioned.
Exploring Further – The Passive FormsAnother Student, Another Teacher: Starting to Talk About the Future
Typo?
“In this video, the teacher invites the student tExploring Further – The Passive FormsAnother Student, Another Teacher: Starting to Talk About the Future
Typo?
“In this video, the teacher invites the student to start talking about ‘next week,’ ‘next year,’ or ‘next year.’”…………………………………
T asked:
T: “Which boxes can you use when you talk about next week, next month, etc.?”
After using “is flying” and “is going to fly,” S responded:
S: “My dad will fly to…”
T: “No, no… You are not allowed to use ‘will.'”S then came up with:
S: “My dad flies…”
T encouraged S to use verbs like travel or go, reinforcing that the present tense can be used to talk about the future.I noticed that S frequently uses will for future references. While he might have already known about using ‘I work’ verb tense for the future, this was a good reminder. Eventually, T allowed S to use will and clarified that it is also acceptable for the future.
This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without directly explaining, would you consider asking questions like, “Have you already bought a flight ticket?” or “Are you just thinking about going without any detailed plans?” to guide him?
Another Student, Another Teacher: Starting with Modals
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘While I Was Sleeping…’
The Value of Pointing on the DiagramThe text says, “The student realizing for himself and correcting himself without any need for grammar talking makes for some very powerful learning.”
I was excited to see this scene:
S: “I dreamed about some horrible ghosts.”
T: “Because?”
This single word prompted S to create the following sentence and realize their mistake!
S: “Because I was watch… Ah, no, no, no, because I had been watching…”How thrilled T must have been when this happened!
Exploring the Whole System
“… despite knowing that the form existed,” many Ss don’t use various forms and instead stick to their comfort zones. This reminded me of an intermediate-level S I teach. Her sentences are quite good, and I rarely need to correct her tense usage. However, I’ve realized she consistently uses tenses she feels comfortable with and avoids combining sentences with when or while to form more complex structures.
This course inspired me to encourage her to explore more verb tenses in her speech. I believe this will expand her ability to create more sophisticated and varied sentences.
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘I Should’ve Done the Shopping Yesterday…’
Using One Situation to Explore the System More Thoroughly
T encouraged S to use if by revisiting the “I work” section to express a similar context, then prompted him to use if with a different verb tense to convey the same idea. S was able to produce:
S: “If I had done the shopping, I wouldn’t have to do the shopping today.”This scene reminded me of Dr. Gattegno’s words: “A lot from a little.” Using a limited situation, the student was able to produce a variety of sentences.
Additionally, it was clear that S’s fluency improved as he repeated earlier sentences multiple times.
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘If I’d Had the Money…’
Letting the Student Find the Solution Themselves
T’s simple drawings of two lines were very effective in helping the student realize they needed to change their sentence from:
S: “If I had the money…”
to:
S: “If I had had the money…”Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘If I Were Rich…’
Prompting the Student to Elaborate
The words “But, then…” were effective prompts. I’d love to incorporate this way into my own classes.First, S pointed to the tense sections based on what they wanted to say. Then, he practiced saying all the sentences without pointing, which helped him practice appropriate speed and flow.
Do Some Practice!
“Practice in any skill is invaluable. When you have students in front of you, your attention needs to be fully on them, and you can only do that if you yourself are thoroughly rehearsed in the technical aspects of this work.”
Exactly! As Dr. Gattegno said: “The students’ job is to work on the language; your job is to work on the student.”
Sometimes, I find myself working on the language alongside my Ss, which prevents me from fully observing what they’re doing and identifying what they need next. The text reminded me how crucial it is to practice the verb tense system thoroughly before class begins.
No. 1—Talking about the FutureRight after introducing will, T moved the will token outside the tense table and asked, “How many of these can be used to talk about next week?”
No. 1—Talking about the FutureRight after introducing will, T moved the will token outside the tense table and asked, “How many of these can be used to talk about next week?” S answered two: I work and I’m working. T then pointed out, S: ‘I was working’-‘I was flying to Brazil, but…’ S realized that the past progressive (I was working) could also be used to talk about the future. I thought this was a great awareness-raising question.
While Vitor might have already been familiar with this usage and had little trouble choosing ‘I was working’ tense, many learners wouldn’t think of it as smoothly, even if they had learned the grammar in the past. This highlights the value of such activities in bridging the gap between knowledge and practical usage.
No. 3—Using would
Usually, when the future will token is moved to the “I worked” section and would is introduced, how do students view the transition from the future to the past?
In this case, would expresses repeated actions in the past.
Vitor seemed to understand this usage well, as he was able to say, “When I was in Paris, I would go to school on foot.” However, for many learners, this transition can be difficult to process. Before will is moved to the “I worked” section, it is associated with the future. Once moved, its meaning changes to refer to past repeated actions. This shift in meaning can be hard to grasp for learners, despite their prior knowledge of the grammar.
Sticking with Whole Sentences
Typo?
“Since it is the examples that are teach students,” (second line from the bottom)
Should this read: “that are to teach students”?
No. 4 and No. 5—Starting with if
S: If I had studied more, I would have had a better score.
T: Can you make that sentence again and add one more word at the end?
S: …but
T repeated this question twice and waited patiently, encouraging S to reflect on what their sentence truly meant and to identify the implied conclusion.
I remember a similar experience from the lesson I took years ago. When I realized that but was coming next, I had a kind of “aha” moment. The following sentences revealed exactly what had happened. Visually, we could also see that two different tense sections were used, which was very effective for understanding both the meaning and the structure of the sentence.
We often omit implied parts of sentences in natural speech, but since that experience, I’ve always incorporated this type of practice in my own classes. I hope and believe that participants in this course will experience a similar moment of clarity.
Lots of Examples
T asked S to make 20 sentences using if. While this sounds like a lot, it’s actually necessary to internalize if sentences effectively.
After completing the past tense section, T moved to the “I work” section, asking S to make more if sentences. This exercise demonstrated that S could almost freely construct conditional sentences across various tenses. With lower-level learners, however, this process would likely require much more time.
No. 6—Exploring Modals
Pointing to will, T asked S for another word to replace it, and S answered may. T then moved to the “I worked” tense and elicited might from S. They continued this process with can, shall, (and optionally ought to and must).
The class then returned to if sentences, and T asked S to make many sentences using modals. This approach reinforces both if sentences and modal usage in an effective, integrated way.
I liked how T encouraged S to say his sentence first and then identify the tenses he had used on the tense table. This step-by-step approach—focusing on one thing at a time—was very effective.
No. 7—I was accepted …
Congratulations to Vitor on being accepted as an English teacher!
I really liked the 3–5-minute video clips throughout the course. They were short enough to maintain focus. Even when I needed to rewatch a clip, it never felt overwhelming.
Additional Thoughts
Using the Verb System in a Tell Me Lesson
A Pronunciation Tool:
For the example sentence “We aren’t working,” I felt that one example wasn’t enough to fully understand the table. I would have appreciated a couple more examples.
The Lesson
After watching the introduction to the verb tenses, course participants may wonder how these concepts will be applied in class. This is a great time to observe the full lesson to find out.
Here are two points I’d like to highlight:
The Amount of Practice:
S: On the following day, I’ll take a plane to come back to France.
S repeated this sentence seven times, focusing on schwa sounds, speed, and smoothness with the T’s guidance. With each repetition, the sentence became more natural and fluent.
S seemed to enjoy the process, likely because he could recognize his own improvement. By the end, he had gained confidence and was practicing for even better fluency.
What stood out to me was that T didn’t move on until S produced the correct sentence in every aspect. This contrasts with some classes where teachers simply say, “Don’t forget to practice after class!” often due to time constraints. In this course, enough practice happens during class time following the idea of ‘Take the time needed to get it right.’
Student Autonomy:
Vitor seems to be a diligent learner by nature, but the class design encouraged him to take even more responsibility for his learning. By the end of the lesson, he was repeating target sentences independently and even requesting extra practice, saying, “Let me practice.”
He also asked for confirmation of his alternative ways to express target sentences, demonstrating an active engagement with the target. This independent attitude will likely carry over after the course, enabling him to continue learning on his own.
3 December 2024 at 12:01 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – relating the forms to students’ lives – expanding a little #3947Laurence,Thank you for your response. I experience the same thing when I work on Japanese. 🙂
As for the link, I still see the same page. Please refer to the attached file.
Laurence,
Thank you for your response. I experience the same thing when I work on Japanese. 🙂
As for the link, I still see the same page. Please refer to the attached file.
3 December 2024 at 06:03 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – relating the forms to students’ lives – expanding a little #3942No 10—More Work on ‘At the Moment’
Talking about Real SituationsIn the earlier class, I felt he wasn’t completely sure about the use of ‘at the moment.’
No 10—More Work on ‘At the Moment’
Talking about Real SituationsIn the earlier class, I felt he wasn’t completely sure about the use of ‘at the moment.’ I was glad he brought it up to clarify.
At 1:35 in the video, T drew lines—one after ‘at the moment’ and the other before it—and had S mark these lines. As soon as S did that, he said, “Ah.” I went, “Aha,” as well. The two lines helped us clearly understand the meaning of ‘at the moment.’ I assume he was almost there in understanding it but wasn’t 100% sure how to set his mind when using the tense. The two lines pushed him to become aware of the real sense/meaning of ‘at the moment.’ (Could we call this T’s “forcing awareness” by using the lines? This is my personal question. I really want to help my students in this way.)
T explained that before the first line (| at the moment |), S wouldn’t have any problems with his Ss, but at the moment, he is struggling with them. After the second line (when the school term is over), the problem will go away. This explanation helped both him and me confirm the meaning of the sentence.No 12 & No 13—Generating More Sentences
T said:
I had two showers today — implies no more showers today.
I’ve had two showers today — implies he might take one more shower before going to bed.
The second implication is new to me—and probably to many other participants as well.‘After’ / ‘When’
The link for ‘Step 8: Exploring More of the Student’s Life’ doesn’t work. We need to access Step 8 by going back to the main page.
2 December 2024 at 12:09 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – relating the verb forms to students’ lives – starting simple #3939Hello,Please disregard my previous post about ‘since’ and ‘for.’ I watched the video again and found that you did mention ‘since’ and ‘for’ being used
Hello,Please disregard my previous post about ‘since’ and ‘for.’ I watched the video again and found that you did mention ‘since’ and ‘for’ being used with both ‘I have worked’ and ‘I have been working’ sentences.
30 November 2024 at 11:57 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – relating the verb forms to students’ lives – starting simple #3937Hello,NO.7
In the statements:
“that there isn’t a time trigger for the ‘I have applied’ form” and “that there is always a time trigger for the other ‘I applied’ form,”
For “I
Hello,NO.7
In the statements:
“that there isn’t a time trigger for the ‘I have applied’ form” and “that there is always a time trigger for the other ‘I applied’ form,”
For “I have applied,” a time trigger doesn’t seem necessary. However, when I tried out “Do some practice!” using the verb “I work / I have worked”, I realized I naturally included since and for with “I have worked” (e.g., since 2022 and for two years). I believe these are correct and could be considered time triggers.
Does this mean the statements at the top apply specifically to “I have applied” but not necessarily to other verbs like work? Or am I misunderstanding the statements?
29 November 2024 at 09:19 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – relating the verb forms to students’ lives – starting simple #3932NO.6Roslyn wrote: … Lucky us! This is an opportunity not to be missed! He doesn’t really need ‘at the moment’ sentences, but he does need ‘I’ve been having’ sentences, so this
NO.6Roslyn wrote: … Lucky us! This is an opportunity not to be missed! He doesn’t really need ‘at the moment’ sentences, but he does need ‘I’ve been having’ sentences, so this is what I gave him.
I’m so glad to witness T’s decision-making moment! In less than a second, T chose which was more important for the S to work on and selected “I’ve been having…” Then, T gave the hint “over.” I could see more decision-making happening behind it.
When I first saw the scene, I was bewildered by what was happening. The second time, I realized what had happened.
29 November 2024 at 05:49 in reply to: Teaching the English verb system – relating the verb forms to students’ lives – starting simple #3928Hello,I’ve just finished No. 6, but there are several things I would like to write about. Let me share them before I finish the whole section on “Relating the forms to students’ lives—st
Hello,I’ve just finished No. 6, but there are several things I would like to write about. Let me share them before I finish the whole section on “Relating the forms to students’ lives—starting simple.”
No. 1 & No. 2—Introducing ‘triggers’
The vertical bar for adverbs was introduced. It was placed between the subject and the verb rod by T. S typed various adverbs there, and the class smoothly transitioned into practicing sentence-making. I sometimes wonder when T decides to ‘give’ or ‘make S do the job.’ In this case, because T was sure that S already knew the position, is that why T placed the bar there? If S’s level were lower than Vitor’s, would you approach this in a different way?No. 3—Yesterday
I jotted down the following: In the video, S said, “I was born 31 years ago.” The ‘be verb past forms’ are not in the Past box. T mentioned the box for ‘Past be + ing.’ Following S’s sentence, the class went to the appropriate box. I thought this was an example of subordination of teaching to learning—not explaining it earlier but ‘working on it when that happens.’ At first, S appeared confused, but I think he understood the idea later.After watching the video, I found the following written explanation: ‘I am hungry’ / ‘I was hungry’ – “The teacher responded to what the student said by adding an important detail to the diagram for situations like this. It is far better to add these kinds of details as they arise and as students explore the system, rather than…”
I was glad that my idea was reflected in the explanation.
This is something participants could do while watching the videos: thinking, “Why did T do that? Why didn’t T do that?” Sometimes, we can see the same topic discussed in the following writings, which helps us deepen our understanding.No. 4—Some more complex sentences
Again, I jotted down the following:
S: “I didn’t go to the march because I was in a training session.”After this sentence, T let S point to the structures in the boxes to visually represent what he was saying. It helped S check how his sentence was structured. This way of practicing seems very effective, as S can clearly confirm which tense to use.
Later in the writing on ‘Pointing on the diagram,’ the importance of pointing was mentioned. Through reading it, I was able to confirm its value, just as Vitor was checking and confirming the appropriate tense boxes with help from T.
No. 5—More about the student’s life
At the end, T asked S, “Does that make sense for you?” S replied, “Yes, it does.” This was the third or fourth time I heard T ask this question. Is the purpose of the question to make sure S reflects on their sentence and confirms that they think it is correct? Could you explain T’s intention in asking this?No. 6—Starting with ‘At the moment’
S: “I’m having a lot of headaches in these last days. … I don’t like this sentence.”T introduced ‘over’ on the chart. [Michiko’s thought: What about ‘at the moment’? Weren’t we working on ‘at the moment’?]
T: “Start with ‘over.’”
S: “Over the last few days,…”
T: “We haven’t got to the right tense.” …
S: “I’ve been having a lot of headaches.”
T: “Exactly.”I have two questions:
1. After this scene, did you go back to ‘at the moment’ and its box for practice, or did you wait until the next opportunity arose?
2. Why was S able to come up with the correct tense when starting with “Over the last few days…”?After writing the above, I started reading “The wrong tense.” It addressed exactly what I was curious about. I enjoyed this way of learning a lot. It felt like discussing the points with you, Roslyn.
As you mentioned in the writing: “Notice that she gave the student as much thinking time as he needed” and “When a word slowly appears before them, it has a much bigger impact on the students than it would do if it had simply appeared all in one go,” these principles can also be applied to the participants of this course. After watching the video, taking time to think over what happened in the class and asking questions in our minds, we often find that the following writings touch upon those questions. This gives us a much bigger impact than simply reading through the material.
Typo
In “Triggers”: “In practice, the problem doesn’t arise very oftenbecause most students …”—a space is needed.Hello Roslyn,You wrote, ‘We have to be careful not to ask too much of them because we don’t want them dropping out, of course!’ I totally understand that. I’m simply putting my feedb
Hello Roslyn,You wrote, ‘We have to be careful not to ask too much of them because we don’t want them dropping out, of course!’ I totally understand that. I’m simply putting my feedback on the table for you. Please feel free to pick up only the points that you and Laurence find important to include in your program.
By the way, I’d like to apologize for including an American seasonal greeting in my last post. Over the past few days, I’ve been writing similar greetings to my American students and managers, and I added it automatically without thinking. Thank you for your understanding!
Roslyn,Thank you for your responses. Here, I’d like to focus on No. 2: “The videos demonstrate many great ways for teachers to help students.”
I watched all the videos again, focu
Roslyn,Thank you for your responses. Here, I’d like to focus on No. 2: “The videos demonstrate many great ways for teachers to help students.”
I watched all the videos again, focusing on the teacher’s perspective—especially how the teacher was trying to raise the students’ awareness rather than providing things the S was looking for. I noticed questions and suggestions such as:
T: “What do you think this one would be? (Pointing at one of the subjects – circle)” (No.1)
T: “What other forms can you think of?”
T: “Can you modify this in some way so that I don’t see the same thing? ” “Let’s move back (to the original ‘I worked’ sentence) – S: Ah, OK. -T: What does this indicate? – S: I can combine the one (past indicator) with the ‘do’ (No.2)
T: Where would you put it? … T: I put this position. (I work.) and YOU chose this position. (“I worked” next to “I work”) – S: It doesn’t matter where it is? – T: What I want to say is there is a correct position. The only one you are sure is this (I work) because I put it here at the beginning. – S: I’m guessing this (I worked) is going to be here (Past box). – T: Why did you choose it? – S: Because it’s the past. “I’ve been working” is closer to the present. (No.5)
As shown above, closely observing what the teacher says to the students reveals how we can encourage students’ awareness. I thought it would be helpful to mention how participants could approach the videos: watching from the students’ perspective, the teacher’s perspective, and switching between both as the class progresses. Watching the videos multiple times would definitely be beneficial.
………………………
Happy Thanksgiving Day! Please don’t feel the need to respond right away. I hope you’re enjoying the holiday!
1. Learning through watching a real class is the most impactful experience for participants.I kept imagining myself switching between the student’s role and Roslyn’s role, back
1. Learning through watching a real class is the most impactful experience for participants.I kept imagining myself switching between the student’s role and Roslyn’s role, back and forth, over and over again. I could clearly see what the student was thinking and wondering.
2. The videos demonstrate many great ways for teachers to help students.
I was excited when Roslyn showed the word charts and encouraged the student to find hints for thinking about the next verb tense after covering the present and past tenses. I reflected on what I would do in that situation. Instead of giving the student hints directly, Roslyn allowed him to spot the hints by himself. He quickly came up with the idea of the present perfect tense.
3. Intermediate and advanced students often think they don’t have significant problems with verb tenses, but that’s a big misconception.
However, this is the reality. I was wondering about the best timing to introduce this practice. Perhaps the ideal moment is when both the student and their teacher notice the student has issues with verb tense usage. However, when this happens, the student might dismiss it as a slip of the tongue because they often recognize and correct the mistake themselves when it’s pointed out.
When do you think would be the best timing to introduce this practice?
4. Watching the videos reminded me of my first experience taking this lesson years ago.
My English level wasn’t very basic at the time, and I thought I already knew a lot about verb tenses. It was a group lesson, and I remember it progressed quite slowly. I questioned why we were doing this. In the beginning, the activities felt mechanical: using a coin for the subject and a plain verb rod that needed another rod to represent the past form. I already knew all of this.
No offense, but I was thinking, “Instead of doing this, I’d rather share real-life stories and get feedback from the teacher to improve my use of verb tenses. That would feel more efficient.” However, when we began the speaking practice involving various verb tenses, I realized there were many things I hadn’t mastered, but it took me a long time to come to this realization.
I’m not analyzing why here—I’m not even sure we can call it a problem. I just wanted to share what happened to me in that class.
5. Many teachers may want or need to implement this method online.
However, not all of us are familiar with Zoom functions such as the student annotation tool, Miro, or Google Whiteboard. Will there be some technical guidance included in this course? It would be incredibly helpful for participants.
For example, I’m currently facing a problem: two of my students say they don’t see the ‘annotation’ button on their Zoom toolbar. I searched for an alternative way to access the function, but it didn’t work. This problem removes one of the most important elements of the online class.
(Laurence, I’ll send you a separate email about this issue later—I’d appreciate your help.)
I see. You are helping participants build up the tense system step by step. The design, where they will practice it five times during the course, seems like more than enough practice.Thank you for t
I see. You are helping participants build up the tense system step by step. The design, where they will practice it five times during the course, seems like more than enough practice.Thank you for the explanation.
Michiko
Continued:
I mean how could we make sure the learners do their work instead of skipping creating their own verb tense tables because the work is very critical.
Roslyn,Thank you for your advice. I understood it except for (‘go’ with the curly 5 squiggle on the board).
When you have time, could you explain what it means, please?
Thanks in adva
Roslyn,Thank you for your advice. I understood it except for (‘go’ with the curly 5 squiggle on the board).
When you have time, could you explain what it means, please?
Thanks in advance.
Hello,Here is my feedback.
- The image of the verb system in Teaching Without Rules provides a clear visual representation of the system and helps us understand its structure.
Hello,Here is my feedback.
- The image of the verb system in Teaching Without Rules provides a clear visual representation of the system and helps us understand its structure.
- The section What to do before the first time you use this technique is especially important for guiding learners through the process of creating their tense tables. It plays a significant role in raising awareness.
This part helps learners:
Think about how many sections need to be included on the large paper. Many of them might never have considered this before.
Realize the difference between traditional grammar terms and this approach. For example, they might instinctively start counting tenses like “present, present progressive, …,” but in this technique, grammar terms are avoided. Instead, sentences such as “I work for …” and “I’m working for …” are used.
Become aware of triggers that naturally accompany verb tenses. While making sentences like “I work for …” or “I’m working for …,” they will notice that words and phrases such as “now,” “every day,” and “at the moment” come to mind. These act as ‘triggers.’
Struggle with expressing verb forms using rods. For instance, they might wonder how to express “-ing,” “-ed,” or “have -ed.” This challenge encourages learners to closely examine the structure of each verb tense.
Discover discrepancies between their tense table and the model. Learners may be surprised to see how different their work is from the model and start questioning why, or even exclaim, “What?!” A typical realization might be, “Where is ‘I will work for …’?”These experiences are essential for learners to reflect and gradually adjust their understanding step by step throughout the lessons.
If they skip this foundational work and move directly to the next section, their learning experience will be significantly diminished compared to those who create the tense table themselves.
I enjoyed doing this activity. It has been a long time since I last worked on the table, but I’m pleased that I haven’t lost much of the work I did earlier. From time to time, I’ve thought about the table and considered using it, but figuring out how to combine it with my regular class content has always been a challenge. I would like to find ways to incorporate parts of it into my class.
‘The Activity That Overwhelmed a Student’I teach Japanese at a language facility in addition to teaching English at a university. There are three students in my Japanese textbook class. One of t
‘The Activity That Overwhelmed a Student’I teach Japanese at a language facility in addition to teaching English at a university. There are three students in my Japanese textbook class. One of them (S1) is a true beginner, while the other two have some basic skills. S1 has been practicing Hiragana sounds and letters (not through the SW color chart) in the past three lessons. Today, I introduced the numbers 0–9. I used a Hiragana table to introduce the numbers by tapping れい、いち、に、さん、… I thought S1 was ready, but he wasn’t.
After introducing the number 5, we were going over 0–5. That’s when I noticed that although S1 was mumbling the numbers, they weren’t sticking with him. He is usually a quick learner, but today he seemed different.
I asked myself why. My guess is that he was focusing so much on reading Hiragana that there wasn’t enough mental space left to learn the numbers. Perhaps he needed more Hiragana practice first, or maybe I should have used a different method to introduce the numbers.
After reflecting on the class, I decided that in the next lesson, I’ll focus exclusively on Hiragana first. I’ll tap the numbers 0–9 and 10–100 without introducing the concept of numbers. Instead, the students will concentrate solely on reading the letters and pronouncing the sounds. After that, we’ll transition to learning numbers. As they practice, S1 might gradually realize that what they were saying during the Hiragana practice were actually numbers all along.
Trying to manage both reading Hiragana and learning numbers simultaneously was overwhelming for S1. For now, these two skills should be practiced separately until he feels more comfortable reading Hiragana.
-
AuthorPosts