- This topic has 6 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by Michiko Watabe.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
21 October 2024 at 19:02 #3373
What do you think from what you’ve seen in Week 1 Introduction to the Verb tense system and setting out the indicative English verb forms?
-
23 November 2024 at 08:46 #3882Hello,
Here is my feedback.
- The image of the verb system in Teaching Without Rules provides a clear visual representation of the system and helps us understand its structure.
Hello,Here is my feedback.
- The image of the verb system in Teaching Without Rules provides a clear visual representation of the system and helps us understand its structure.
- The section What to do before the first time you use this technique is especially important for guiding learners through the process of creating their tense tables. It plays a significant role in raising awareness.
This part helps learners:
Think about how many sections need to be included on the large paper. Many of them might never have considered this before.
Realize the difference between traditional grammar terms and this approach. For example, they might instinctively start counting tenses like “present, present progressive, …,” but in this technique, grammar terms are avoided. Instead, sentences such as “I work for …” and “I’m working for …” are used.
Become aware of triggers that naturally accompany verb tenses. While making sentences like “I work for …” or “I’m working for …,” they will notice that words and phrases such as “now,” “every day,” and “at the moment” come to mind. These act as ‘triggers.’
Struggle with expressing verb forms using rods. For instance, they might wonder how to express “-ing,” “-ed,” or “have -ed.” This challenge encourages learners to closely examine the structure of each verb tense.
Discover discrepancies between their tense table and the model. Learners may be surprised to see how different their work is from the model and start questioning why, or even exclaim, “What?!” A typical realization might be, “Where is ‘I will work for …’?”These experiences are essential for learners to reflect and gradually adjust their understanding step by step throughout the lessons.
If they skip this foundational work and move directly to the next section, their learning experience will be significantly diminished compared to those who create the tense table themselves.
I enjoyed doing this activity. It has been a long time since I last worked on the table, but I’m pleased that I haven’t lost much of the work I did earlier. From time to time, I’ve thought about the table and considered using it, but figuring out how to combine it with my regular class content has always been a challenge. I would like to find ways to incorporate parts of it into my class.
-
26 November 2024 at 06:51 #39171. Learning through watching a real class is the most impactful experience for participants.
I kept imagining myself switching between the student’s role and Roslyn’s role, back
1. Learning through watching a real class is the most impactful experience for participants.I kept imagining myself switching between the student’s role and Roslyn’s role, back and forth, over and over again. I could clearly see what the student was thinking and wondering.
2. The videos demonstrate many great ways for teachers to help students.
I was excited when Roslyn showed the word charts and encouraged the student to find hints for thinking about the next verb tense after covering the present and past tenses. I reflected on what I would do in that situation. Instead of giving the student hints directly, Roslyn allowed him to spot the hints by himself. He quickly came up with the idea of the present perfect tense.
3. Intermediate and advanced students often think they don’t have significant problems with verb tenses, but that’s a big misconception.
However, this is the reality. I was wondering about the best timing to introduce this practice. Perhaps the ideal moment is when both the student and their teacher notice the student has issues with verb tense usage. However, when this happens, the student might dismiss it as a slip of the tongue because they often recognize and correct the mistake themselves when it’s pointed out.
When do you think would be the best timing to introduce this practice?
4. Watching the videos reminded me of my first experience taking this lesson years ago.
My English level wasn’t very basic at the time, and I thought I already knew a lot about verb tenses. It was a group lesson, and I remember it progressed quite slowly. I questioned why we were doing this. In the beginning, the activities felt mechanical: using a coin for the subject and a plain verb rod that needed another rod to represent the past form. I already knew all of this.
No offense, but I was thinking, “Instead of doing this, I’d rather share real-life stories and get feedback from the teacher to improve my use of verb tenses. That would feel more efficient.” However, when we began the speaking practice involving various verb tenses, I realized there were many things I hadn’t mastered, but it took me a long time to come to this realization.
I’m not analyzing why here—I’m not even sure we can call it a problem. I just wanted to share what happened to me in that class.
5. Many teachers may want or need to implement this method online.
However, not all of us are familiar with Zoom functions such as the student annotation tool, Miro, or Google Whiteboard. Will there be some technical guidance included in this course? It would be incredibly helpful for participants.
For example, I’m currently facing a problem: two of my students say they don’t see the ‘annotation’ button on their Zoom toolbar. I searched for an alternative way to access the function, but it didn’t work. This problem removes one of the most important elements of the online class.
(Laurence, I’ll send you a separate email about this issue later—I’d appreciate your help.)
-
26 November 2024 at 09:14 #3919Hi Michiko;
Going through your ideas one by one…
Point 1. I can say, like you, that I can usually see fairly clearly what a student is thinking and wondering, and this is important because it
Hi Michiko;Going through your ideas one by one…
Point 1. I can say, like you, that I can usually see fairly clearly what a student is thinking and wondering, and this is important because it allows me to tailor the class to my student’s exact needs in the moment.
Point 2. I have to adapt what I do to the student’s level. Vitor has a good level, so I could do this with him. With other students, it would be impossible.
Point 3. My students are often reluctant to speak. I can’t simply ask them to talk and expect they will do so. Going through the forms as suggested in this presentation—using each of the forms with triggers to make sentences —gets them used to simply making statements about themselves. With intermediate and advanced students I usually start very soon after the beginning of the course. This way, both they and I find mistakes they didn’t know they had been making. Misconceptions are made clear quite quickly.
Point 4. I think I remember the course you are talking about. It was indeed a long time ago; in the late 1990’s I think. Your level of English was much higher than the level of the other students in the course, none of whom could have gone on to become an English teacher. You knew all this, but I wasn’t sure they all did. If no mistakes are made, then this part can be worked through quickly, but this is rare.
Point 5. We’ll have to talk aout this. It isn’t part of the course at the moment. One problem is that technology changes so fast; However we can talk about any problems you have off-line.
Roslyn
-
28 November 2024 at 02:48 #3921Roslyn,
Thank you for your responses. Here, I’d like to focus on No. 2: “The videos demonstrate many great ways for teachers to help students.”
I watched all the videos again, focu
Roslyn,Thank you for your responses. Here, I’d like to focus on No. 2: “The videos demonstrate many great ways for teachers to help students.”
I watched all the videos again, focusing on the teacher’s perspective—especially how the teacher was trying to raise the students’ awareness rather than providing things the S was looking for. I noticed questions and suggestions such as:
T: “What do you think this one would be? (Pointing at one of the subjects – circle)” (No.1)
T: “What other forms can you think of?”
T: “Can you modify this in some way so that I don’t see the same thing? ” “Let’s move back (to the original ‘I worked’ sentence) – S: Ah, OK. -T: What does this indicate? – S: I can combine the one (past indicator) with the ‘do’ (No.2)
T: Where would you put it? … T: I put this position. (I work.) and YOU chose this position. (“I worked” next to “I work”) – S: It doesn’t matter where it is? – T: What I want to say is there is a correct position. The only one you are sure is this (I work) because I put it here at the beginning. – S: I’m guessing this (I worked) is going to be here (Past box). – T: Why did you choose it? – S: Because it’s the past. “I’ve been working” is closer to the present. (No.5)
As shown above, closely observing what the teacher says to the students reveals how we can encourage students’ awareness. I thought it would be helpful to mention how participants could approach the videos: watching from the students’ perspective, the teacher’s perspective, and switching between both as the class progresses. Watching the videos multiple times would definitely be beneficial.
………………………
Happy Thanksgiving Day! Please don’t feel the need to respond right away. I hope you’re enjoying the holiday!
-
28 November 2024 at 08:29 #3923Hi Michiko,
Thanks very much for your detailed feedback. It’s very helpful for us.
I think Laurence and I might look into the idea of asking people to watch the videos —at least the shorter
Hi Michiko,Thanks very much for your detailed feedback. It’s very helpful for us.
I think Laurence and I might look into the idea of asking people to watch the videos —at least the shorter ones— twice; once from the student’s perspective, and a second time to see what the teacher is doing and saying.
We have to be careful not to ask too much of them because we don’t want them dropping out, of course!
Thanks again,
Roslyn
-
29 November 2024 at 00:07 #3926Hello Roslyn,
You wrote, ‘We have to be careful not to ask too much of them because we don’t want them dropping out, of course!’ I totally understand that. I’m simply putting my feedb
Hello Roslyn,You wrote, ‘We have to be careful not to ask too much of them because we don’t want them dropping out, of course!’ I totally understand that. I’m simply putting my feedback on the table for you. Please feel free to pick up only the points that you and Laurence find important to include in your program.
By the way, I’d like to apologize for including an American seasonal greeting in my last post. Over the past few days, I’ve been writing similar greetings to my American students and managers, and I added it automatically without thinking. Thank you for your understanding!
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.