‘This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without dire
‘This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without directly explaining, would you consider asking questions like, “Have you already bought a flight ticket?” or “Are you just thinking about going without any detailed plans?” to guide him?’
It’s difficult to answer your question, because everything does depend on the student and how much we’ve worked together. Having said that, if intermediate or advanced students ask questions like this I usually respond by saying: ‘Make a sentence and we’ll see’ or ‘Tell me about the situation you’re thinking about. Remember every sentence must be true.’
The thing is:
- I want them talking as much as possible
- It is much better for these details to emerge from the students talking about the situation
- Often just the word ‘because’ or ‘but’ or ‘and’ is enough to elicit the extra information
Having said that I do sometimes ask for the kinds of details you mention, since sometimes it’s only when I understand the situation I know which box their sentence should be in.
Sometimes when they tell me more about the situation we have to backtrack with their sentence and recast it using a different tense from where we’d started. I always think this ‘backtracking’ provides extra learning for the student. And usually when that happens I make sure they do a bit of extra practice telling the whole story so that it all ties together in their minds.