Another Student, Another Teacher: Starting to Talk About the Future
Typo?
“In this video, the teacher invites the student t
Another Student, Another Teacher: Starting to Talk About the Future
Typo?
“In this video, the teacher invites the student to start talking about ‘next week,’ ‘next year,’ or ‘next year.’”
…………………………………
T asked:
T: “Which boxes can you use when you talk about next week, next month, etc.?”
After using “is flying” and “is going to fly,” S responded:
S: “My dad will fly to…”
T: “No, no… You are not allowed to use ‘will.'”
S then came up with:
S: “My dad flies…”
T encouraged S to use verbs like travel or go, reinforcing that the present tense can be used to talk about the future.
I noticed that S frequently uses will for future references. While he might have already known about using ‘I work’ verb tense for the future, this was a good reminder. Eventually, T allowed S to use will and clarified that it is also acceptable for the future.
This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without directly explaining, would you consider asking questions like, “Have you already bought a flight ticket?” or “Are you just thinking about going without any detailed plans?” to guide him?
Another Student, Another Teacher: Starting with Modals
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘While I Was Sleeping…’
The Value of Pointing on the Diagram
The text says, “The student realizing for himself and correcting himself without any need for grammar talking makes for some very powerful learning.”
I was excited to see this scene:
S: “I dreamed about some horrible ghosts.”
T: “Because?”
This single word prompted S to create the following sentence and realize their mistake!
S: “Because I was watch… Ah, no, no, no, because I had been watching…”
How thrilled T must have been when this happened!
Exploring the Whole System
“… despite knowing that the form existed,” many Ss don’t use various forms and instead stick to their comfort zones. This reminded me of an intermediate-level S I teach. Her sentences are quite good, and I rarely need to correct her tense usage. However, I’ve realized she consistently uses tenses she feels comfortable with and avoids combining sentences with when or while to form more complex structures.
This course inspired me to encourage her to explore more verb tenses in her speech. I believe this will expand her ability to create more sophisticated and varied sentences.
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘I Should’ve Done the Shopping Yesterday…’
Using One Situation to Explore the System More Thoroughly
T encouraged S to use if by revisiting the “I work” section to express a similar context, then prompted him to use if with a different verb tense to convey the same idea. S was able to produce:
S: “If I had done the shopping, I wouldn’t have to do the shopping today.”
This scene reminded me of Dr. Gattegno’s words: “A lot from a little.” Using a limited situation, the student was able to produce a variety of sentences.
Additionally, it was clear that S’s fluency improved as he repeated earlier sentences multiple times.
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘If I’d Had the Money…’
Letting the Student Find the Solution Themselves
T’s simple drawings of two lines were very effective in helping the student realize they needed to change their sentence from:
S: “If I had the money…”
to:
S: “If I had had the money…”
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘If I Were Rich…’
Prompting the Student to Elaborate
The words “But, then…” were effective prompts. I’d love to incorporate this way into my own classes.
First, S pointed to the tense sections based on what they wanted to say. Then, he practiced saying all the sentences without pointing, which helped him practice appropriate speed and flow.
Do Some Practice!
“Practice in any skill is invaluable. When you have students in front of you, your attention needs to be fully on them, and you can only do that if you yourself are thoroughly rehearsed in the technical aspects of this work.”
Exactly! As Dr. Gattegno said: “The students’ job is to work on the language; your job is to work on the student.”
Sometimes, I find myself working on the language alongside my Ss, which prevents me from fully observing what they’re doing and identifying what they need next. The text reminded me how crucial it is to practice the verb tense system thoroughly before class begins.