- This topic has 13 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by Michiko Watabe.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
21 October 2024 at 19:14 #3393In this section we’ve looked at the future, the modals etc and how once students are familiar with the system it can be used in actual lessons. Tell us your thoughts about this part of the couIn this section we’ve looked at the future, the modals etc and how once students are familiar with the system it can be used in actual lessons. Tell us your thoughts about this part of the course.
-
7 December 2024 at 05:18 #3961No. 1—Talking about the Future
Right after introducing will, T moved the will token outside the tense table and asked, “How many of these can be used to talk about next week?”
No. 1—Talking about the FutureRight after introducing will, T moved the will token outside the tense table and asked, “How many of these can be used to talk about next week?” S answered two: I work and I’m working. T then pointed out, S: ‘I was working’-‘I was flying to Brazil, but…’ S realized that the past progressive (I was working) could also be used to talk about the future. I thought this was a great awareness-raising question.
While Vitor might have already been familiar with this usage and had little trouble choosing ‘I was working’ tense, many learners wouldn’t think of it as smoothly, even if they had learned the grammar in the past. This highlights the value of such activities in bridging the gap between knowledge and practical usage.
No. 3—Using would
Usually, when the future will token is moved to the “I worked” section and would is introduced, how do students view the transition from the future to the past?
In this case, would expresses repeated actions in the past.
Vitor seemed to understand this usage well, as he was able to say, “When I was in Paris, I would go to school on foot.” However, for many learners, this transition can be difficult to process. Before will is moved to the “I worked” section, it is associated with the future. Once moved, its meaning changes to refer to past repeated actions. This shift in meaning can be hard to grasp for learners, despite their prior knowledge of the grammar.
Sticking with Whole Sentences
Typo?
“Since it is the examples that are teach students,” (second line from the bottom)
Should this read: “that are to teach students”?
No. 4 and No. 5—Starting with if
S: If I had studied more, I would have had a better score.
T: Can you make that sentence again and add one more word at the end?
S: …but
T repeated this question twice and waited patiently, encouraging S to reflect on what their sentence truly meant and to identify the implied conclusion.
I remember a similar experience from the lesson I took years ago. When I realized that but was coming next, I had a kind of “aha” moment. The following sentences revealed exactly what had happened. Visually, we could also see that two different tense sections were used, which was very effective for understanding both the meaning and the structure of the sentence.
We often omit implied parts of sentences in natural speech, but since that experience, I’ve always incorporated this type of practice in my own classes. I hope and believe that participants in this course will experience a similar moment of clarity.
Lots of Examples
T asked S to make 20 sentences using if. While this sounds like a lot, it’s actually necessary to internalize if sentences effectively.
After completing the past tense section, T moved to the “I work” section, asking S to make more if sentences. This exercise demonstrated that S could almost freely construct conditional sentences across various tenses. With lower-level learners, however, this process would likely require much more time.
No. 6—Exploring Modals
Pointing to will, T asked S for another word to replace it, and S answered may. T then moved to the “I worked” tense and elicited might from S. They continued this process with can, shall, (and optionally ought to and must).
The class then returned to if sentences, and T asked S to make many sentences using modals. This approach reinforces both if sentences and modal usage in an effective, integrated way.
I liked how T encouraged S to say his sentence first and then identify the tenses he had used on the tense table. This step-by-step approach—focusing on one thing at a time—was very effective.
No. 7—I was accepted …
Congratulations to Vitor on being accepted as an English teacher!
I really liked the 3–5-minute video clips throughout the course. They were short enough to maintain focus. Even when I needed to rewatch a clip, it never felt overwhelming.
Additional Thoughts
Using the Verb System in a Tell Me Lesson
A Pronunciation Tool:
For the example sentence “We aren’t working,” I felt that one example wasn’t enough to fully understand the table. I would have appreciated a couple more examples.
The Lesson
After watching the introduction to the verb tenses, course participants may wonder how these concepts will be applied in class. This is a great time to observe the full lesson to find out.
Here are two points I’d like to highlight:
The Amount of Practice:
S: On the following day, I’ll take a plane to come back to France.
S repeated this sentence seven times, focusing on schwa sounds, speed, and smoothness with the T’s guidance. With each repetition, the sentence became more natural and fluent.
S seemed to enjoy the process, likely because he could recognize his own improvement. By the end, he had gained confidence and was practicing for even better fluency.
What stood out to me was that T didn’t move on until S produced the correct sentence in every aspect. This contrasts with some classes where teachers simply say, “Don’t forget to practice after class!” often due to time constraints. In this course, enough practice happens during class time following the idea of ‘Take the time needed to get it right.’
Student Autonomy:
Vitor seems to be a diligent learner by nature, but the class design encouraged him to take even more responsibility for his learning. By the end of the lesson, he was repeating target sentences independently and even requesting extra practice, saying, “Let me practice.”
He also asked for confirmation of his alternative ways to express target sentences, demonstrating an active engagement with the target. This independent attitude will likely carry over after the course, enabling him to continue learning on his own.
-
7 December 2024 at 19:21 #3964
Michiko, Great feedback and comments! Thank you. As for the typo, I’ve fixed it. We meant: ‘“Since it is the examples that teach students” …
-
10 December 2024 at 02:51 #3967Exploring Further – The Passive Forms
Another Student, Another Teacher: Starting to Talk About the Future
Typo?
“In this video, the teacher invites the student tExploring Further – The Passive FormsAnother Student, Another Teacher: Starting to Talk About the Future
Typo?
“In this video, the teacher invites the student to start talking about ‘next week,’ ‘next year,’ or ‘next year.’”…………………………………
T asked:
T: “Which boxes can you use when you talk about next week, next month, etc.?”
After using “is flying” and “is going to fly,” S responded:
S: “My dad will fly to…”
T: “No, no… You are not allowed to use ‘will.'”S then came up with:
S: “My dad flies…”
T encouraged S to use verbs like travel or go, reinforcing that the present tense can be used to talk about the future.I noticed that S frequently uses will for future references. While he might have already known about using ‘I work’ verb tense for the future, this was a good reminder. Eventually, T allowed S to use will and clarified that it is also acceptable for the future.
This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without directly explaining, would you consider asking questions like, “Have you already bought a flight ticket?” or “Are you just thinking about going without any detailed plans?” to guide him?
Another Student, Another Teacher: Starting with Modals
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘While I Was Sleeping…’
The Value of Pointing on the DiagramThe text says, “The student realizing for himself and correcting himself without any need for grammar talking makes for some very powerful learning.”
I was excited to see this scene:
S: “I dreamed about some horrible ghosts.”
T: “Because?”
This single word prompted S to create the following sentence and realize their mistake!
S: “Because I was watch… Ah, no, no, no, because I had been watching…”How thrilled T must have been when this happened!
Exploring the Whole System
“… despite knowing that the form existed,” many Ss don’t use various forms and instead stick to their comfort zones. This reminded me of an intermediate-level S I teach. Her sentences are quite good, and I rarely need to correct her tense usage. However, I’ve realized she consistently uses tenses she feels comfortable with and avoids combining sentences with when or while to form more complex structures.
This course inspired me to encourage her to explore more verb tenses in her speech. I believe this will expand her ability to create more sophisticated and varied sentences.
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘I Should’ve Done the Shopping Yesterday…’
Using One Situation to Explore the System More Thoroughly
T encouraged S to use if by revisiting the “I work” section to express a similar context, then prompted him to use if with a different verb tense to convey the same idea. S was able to produce:
S: “If I had done the shopping, I wouldn’t have to do the shopping today.”This scene reminded me of Dr. Gattegno’s words: “A lot from a little.” Using a limited situation, the student was able to produce a variety of sentences.
Additionally, it was clear that S’s fluency improved as he repeated earlier sentences multiple times.
Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘If I’d Had the Money…’
Letting the Student Find the Solution Themselves
T’s simple drawings of two lines were very effective in helping the student realize they needed to change their sentence from:
S: “If I had the money…”
to:
S: “If I had had the money…”Another Student, Another Teacher: ‘If I Were Rich…’
Prompting the Student to Elaborate
The words “But, then…” were effective prompts. I’d love to incorporate this way into my own classes.First, S pointed to the tense sections based on what they wanted to say. Then, he practiced saying all the sentences without pointing, which helped him practice appropriate speed and flow.
Do Some Practice!
“Practice in any skill is invaluable. When you have students in front of you, your attention needs to be fully on them, and you can only do that if you yourself are thoroughly rehearsed in the technical aspects of this work.”
Exactly! As Dr. Gattegno said: “The students’ job is to work on the language; your job is to work on the student.”
Sometimes, I find myself working on the language alongside my Ss, which prevents me from fully observing what they’re doing and identifying what they need next. The text reminded me how crucial it is to practice the verb tense system thoroughly before class begins.
-
10 December 2024 at 08:09 #3969You asked:
‘This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without dire
You asked:‘This made me wonder: if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking. Without directly explaining, would you consider asking questions like, “Have you already bought a flight ticket?” or “Are you just thinking about going without any detailed plans?” to guide him?’
It’s difficult to answer your question, because everything does depend on the student and how much we’ve worked together. Having said that, if intermediate or advanced students ask questions like this I usually respond by saying: ‘Make a sentence and we’ll see’ or ‘Tell me about the situation you’re thinking about. Remember every sentence must be true.’
The thing is:
- I want them talking as much as possible
- It is much better for these details to emerge from the students talking about the situation
- Often just the word ‘because’ or ‘but’ or ‘and’ is enough to elicit the extra information
Having said that I do sometimes ask for the kinds of details you mention, since sometimes it’s only when I understand the situation I know which box their sentence should be in.
Sometimes when they tell me more about the situation we have to backtrack with their sentence and recast it using a different tense from where we’d started. I always think this ‘backtracking’ provides extra learning for the student. And usually when that happens I make sure they do a bit of extra practice telling the whole story so that it all ties together in their minds.
-
10 December 2024 at 09:07 #3971Laurence,
I understand your point. Thank you for your response.
With the new or detailed information students share with you, “we have to backtrack through their sentence and recast it us
Laurence,I understand your point. Thank you for your response.
With the new or detailed information students share with you, “we have to backtrack through their sentence and recast it using a different tense from where we started.”
I’ve seen examples of this in the videos. I thought that by doing this, students would be able to express themselves more accurately about what they want to say. I’m sure this would help them feel more confident and satisfied. Also, by doing this, they may find answers to their questions, such as the one I mentioned.
-
11 December 2024 at 10:45 #3976Hi Michiko,
You wrote “if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking.”
It’s
Hi Michiko,You wrote “if S had asked when to use will travel, travel, or is traveling for the future, how would T have handled it? If I were the S, I would feel like asking.”
It’s a good question. The students have a right to receive some sort of reply. And I have an obligation to know for myself what a reply might be, even if I decide not to give it to them.
I think the easiest way of describing what the Present Simple is used for is to say that it’s like vocabulary. It’s used every time nothing extra is required except who, the subject, and what, the verb. No ‘past’, no ‘before now’ and no ‘limitations in time’. The words plus the context do the only work that is necessary.
This is why there can seem to be so very different uses of the Present Simple when you read a grammar book. The form really is ‘simple’; there’s nothing except the vocabulary.
-
13 December 2024 at 02:59 #3982Roslyn,
I read your response 5 or 6 times to understand what you said about the Simple Present tense: ‘…it’s like vocabulary… no “past,” no “before now,” a
Roslyn,I read your response 5 or 6 times to understand what you said about the Simple Present tense: ‘…it’s like vocabulary… no “past,” no “before now,” and no “limitations in time.’ I think I understand it, although perhaps only vaguely for now. I guess that’s why this tense is used for statements like ‘The earth is round.’
-
13 December 2024 at 09:25 #3986Hi Michiko,
Yes, I agree that this might be difficult to grasp; it’s just vocabulary.
Let me have another try at describing it. Image that it isn’t a verb form at all. In what I
Hi Michiko,Yes, I agree that this might be difficult to grasp; it’s just vocabulary.
Let me have another try at describing it. Image that it isn’t a verb form at all. In what I want to say to you, I don’t need past, I don’t need before now, I don’t need limited duration. All I need is the words to give you my message. I arrive at six pm. Since you know I’m coming, and you know which station I will be arriving at, all you need is the vocabulary of the situation to get my meaning. If I only told you six pm, you might wonder if I arrive at your end or if I leave from my end at that time, so to be quite clear, I need arrive in my sentence. But I don’t need any complications like past, limited duration, before now or something to indicate the future. I only need the bare minimum; just the words.
I suggest you look in a grammar book at the examples they give. You’ll see that grammar books give lots of explanations and try to name the various uses—eternal truths, habitual occupations, etc—but in the end, none of the examples needs more than the verb used simply as vocabulary.
Does this help?
-
14 December 2024 at 08:01 #3988Roslyn,
The example you provided has helped me better understand the use of the Present Simple.
As I often use grammar textbooks in class, I frequently encounter detailed explanations of the rules.
Roslyn,The example you provided has helped me better understand the use of the Present Simple.
As I often use grammar textbooks in class, I frequently encounter detailed explanations of the rules. This may be why I thought about a situation where a student might ask a question about the difference between work, is going to work, and will work. I realize my question is: Should teachers guide students to explore these differences, or is it unnecessary?
For instance, we elicit sentences from students. If a student says, “I go to work by bus. My bus will come at 7:30 tomorrow,” the use of ‘will’ here feels unnecessary because it refers to a bus schedule. We can simply say, “My bus comes at 7:30.”
[If I apply your explanation to this example, the student doesn’t need to complicate the sentence with concepts like past, limited duration, or markers for the future. They only need the bare essentials—the words: “My bus / come / 7:30” becomes “My bus comes at 7:30.” (Am I understanding this correctly?)]
According to Azar’s grammar book, “The simple present is used to express habitual or everyday activities.” Similarly, Swan’s Practical English Usage states, “We can use the simple present to talk about the future… when referring to events that are part of a timetable or a regular schedule.”
Would you say it’s important for students to become aware of these differences, as highlighted in grammar books? Or can we simply wait for opportunities when students bring in examples naturally, allowing us to explore these distinctions in context?
If we work through the verb tense system step by step—work, is going to work, and will work—will students naturally acquire a sense of these differences even if we don’t explicitly emphasize them?
I know you’re busy, so there’s no rush to reply. I’m happy to wait until you have time to share your thoughts.
Thank you for your guidance.
-
14 December 2024 at 09:14 #3990Hi Michiko,
These are difficult questions, perhaps in part because the answer depends to a large extent on what else has already been worked on. Coming back to the lessons with Vitor, when he says, <
Hi Michiko,These are difficult questions, perhaps in part because the answer depends to a large extent on what else has already been worked on. Coming back to the lessons with Vitor, when he says, I’m flying to Brazil in July, he’s expressing the fact that he’s in the planning process; he’s excited; this is what is occupying his mind ‘at the moment’. If we’ve already worked on the ‘at the moment’ form, it’s fine. If he had said I fly to Brazil in July, I would have understood that he wasn’t mentally in the planning process, he was just giving me the information and nothing else. The word fly is working just as vocabulary. I could check with him by asking him to go on with his story, which might lead to I land in Sao Paulo, then I fly to Rio to see friends, then we go on to … All excellent. The verbs are nothing more than vocabulary. So I could ask questions inspired by the context which of course both the student and I know already.
I can imagine myself saying to a class ‘Let’s use this form simply as vocabulary.’ This might produce simple factual sentences like, I don’t eat breakfast. I dislike coffee. Water boils at 100° at sea level. And perhaps most of the kinds of examples you find in grammar books. This might be considered a grammar lesson, but there is a major difference; the students are producing the textbook rather than reading the author’s examples. Now that’s a real difference!
And yes, I think with time and contact with native speakers, students will gradually build up a sense of how the language is spoken. I know I did this in French and it was quite successful. I simply observed how people used the language, and did the same.
-
16 December 2024 at 00:07 #3992Roslyn,
Thank you very much for using specific examples of the S’s sentences and what you might say in class. Those really helped me understand how to deal with the Simple Present.
You wrote,
Roslyn,Thank you very much for using specific examples of the S’s sentences and what you might say in class. Those really helped me understand how to deal with the Simple Present.
You wrote, ‘I did this in French.’ Do you mean you worked on the English verb system with
French speakers?
-
16 December 2024 at 07:57 #3994
Hi Michiko,
No, I meant that this is how I learned to speak French, once I had reached a low intermediate level. I noted how people use the language and used it in the same way.
-
16 December 2024 at 12:17 #3996Roslyn,
Thank you for clarifying my misunderstanding. It’s clear now.
I don’t think I’ve specifically observed how native English speakers use the verb tense system in speech. I
Roslyn,Thank you for clarifying my misunderstanding. It’s clear now.
I don’t think I’ve specifically observed how native English speakers use the verb tense system in speech. I’ll give it a try. (I’ve mainly focused on written English.)
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.