- This topic has 6 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 1 year ago by Michiko Watabe.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
21 October 2024 at 19:07 #3380In this section we’ve looked at working with your students to relate experiences from their lives to the English indicative verb forms. What are your thoughts about what you’ve watched aIn this section we’ve looked at working with your students to relate experiences from their lives to the English indicative verb forms. What are your thoughts about what you’ve watched and read?
-
29 November 2024 at 05:49 #3928Hello,
I’ve just finished No. 6, but there are several things I would like to write about. Let me share them before I finish the whole section on “Relating the forms to students’ lives—st
Hello,I’ve just finished No. 6, but there are several things I would like to write about. Let me share them before I finish the whole section on “Relating the forms to students’ lives—starting simple.”
No. 1 & No. 2—Introducing ‘triggers’
The vertical bar for adverbs was introduced. It was placed between the subject and the verb rod by T. S typed various adverbs there, and the class smoothly transitioned into practicing sentence-making. I sometimes wonder when T decides to ‘give’ or ‘make S do the job.’ In this case, because T was sure that S already knew the position, is that why T placed the bar there? If S’s level were lower than Vitor’s, would you approach this in a different way?No. 3—Yesterday
I jotted down the following: In the video, S said, “I was born 31 years ago.” The ‘be verb past forms’ are not in the Past box. T mentioned the box for ‘Past be + ing.’ Following S’s sentence, the class went to the appropriate box. I thought this was an example of subordination of teaching to learning—not explaining it earlier but ‘working on it when that happens.’ At first, S appeared confused, but I think he understood the idea later.After watching the video, I found the following written explanation: ‘I am hungry’ / ‘I was hungry’ – “The teacher responded to what the student said by adding an important detail to the diagram for situations like this. It is far better to add these kinds of details as they arise and as students explore the system, rather than…”
I was glad that my idea was reflected in the explanation.
This is something participants could do while watching the videos: thinking, “Why did T do that? Why didn’t T do that?” Sometimes, we can see the same topic discussed in the following writings, which helps us deepen our understanding.No. 4—Some more complex sentences
Again, I jotted down the following:
S: “I didn’t go to the march because I was in a training session.”After this sentence, T let S point to the structures in the boxes to visually represent what he was saying. It helped S check how his sentence was structured. This way of practicing seems very effective, as S can clearly confirm which tense to use.
Later in the writing on ‘Pointing on the diagram,’ the importance of pointing was mentioned. Through reading it, I was able to confirm its value, just as Vitor was checking and confirming the appropriate tense boxes with help from T.
No. 5—More about the student’s life
At the end, T asked S, “Does that make sense for you?” S replied, “Yes, it does.” This was the third or fourth time I heard T ask this question. Is the purpose of the question to make sure S reflects on their sentence and confirms that they think it is correct? Could you explain T’s intention in asking this?No. 6—Starting with ‘At the moment’
S: “I’m having a lot of headaches in these last days. … I don’t like this sentence.”T introduced ‘over’ on the chart. [Michiko’s thought: What about ‘at the moment’? Weren’t we working on ‘at the moment’?]
T: “Start with ‘over.’”
S: “Over the last few days,…”
T: “We haven’t got to the right tense.” …
S: “I’ve been having a lot of headaches.”
T: “Exactly.”I have two questions:
1. After this scene, did you go back to ‘at the moment’ and its box for practice, or did you wait until the next opportunity arose?
2. Why was S able to come up with the correct tense when starting with “Over the last few days…”?After writing the above, I started reading “The wrong tense.” It addressed exactly what I was curious about. I enjoyed this way of learning a lot. It felt like discussing the points with you, Roslyn.
As you mentioned in the writing: “Notice that she gave the student as much thinking time as he needed” and “When a word slowly appears before them, it has a much bigger impact on the students than it would do if it had simply appeared all in one go,” these principles can also be applied to the participants of this course. After watching the video, taking time to think over what happened in the class and asking questions in our minds, we often find that the following writings touch upon those questions. This gives us a much bigger impact than simply reading through the material.
Typo
In “Triggers”: “In practice, the problem doesn’t arise very oftenbecause most students …”—a space is needed. -
29 November 2024 at 08:41 #3930HI Michiko,
I’ll reply one by one, starting with 1 and 2.
I would place the bar for any class. In fact, how else could I do it? They don’t know what it means yet. I can’t place it
HI Michiko,I’ll reply one by one, starting with 1 and 2.
I would place the bar for any class. In fact, how else could I do it? They don’t know what it means yet. I can’t place it in the wrong place: that would encourage students to say the wrong thing, so I simply place it in its position. However, at this level, the students should have some sense that this is where it should go. They aren’t beginners.
N° 3. It would be useful for participants to do what you’re suggesting. We might think of adding a sentence somewhere telling them, ‘as you work through the material, ask yourself why the teacher is doing this,? why not this? If you don’t find an answer to these questions, ask us’.
N° 4. Pointing is essential. It makes such a big difference. It allows the teacher to know more precisely where the student is at. This is true whatever is being worked on and whatever the level.
N° 5. I ask this more and more often. (I said it several times yesterday in classes.) It give the student a moment to think about what has been done or said, perhaps to zoom out if we have been looking at some detail; or to zoom in on it differently. In any case, it seems to change the student’s perspective a little.
N° 6. remember this student has a very high level. This was a good opportunity to get him to use this form spontaneously. These opportunities don’t come up very often so I seized it. Lucky us! This is an opportunity not to be missed! He doesn’t really need ‘at the moment’ sentences, but he does need ‘I’ve been having’ sentences, so this is what I gave him.
‘In these last days’ isn’t English although his idea is easy to understand. I think changing the first word to ‘over’ —> “Over the last few days” allowed him to change his mindset. It took him out of ‘at the moment’ and cast him back, and he handled it very well, using the right form immediately.
And you’re right, we ‘re trying to subordinate this course to its students’ needs. They will get as much out of it as they put into it, and we will help as they go along.
Thanks for the typo. That’s Laurence’s job.
-
29 November 2024 at 09:19 #3932NO.6
Roslyn wrote: … Lucky us! This is an opportunity not to be missed! He doesn’t really need ‘at the moment’ sentences, but he does need ‘I’ve been having’ sentences, so this
NO.6Roslyn wrote: … Lucky us! This is an opportunity not to be missed! He doesn’t really need ‘at the moment’ sentences, but he does need ‘I’ve been having’ sentences, so this is what I gave him.
I’m so glad to witness T’s decision-making moment! In less than a second, T chose which was more important for the S to work on and selected “I’ve been having…” Then, T gave the hint “over.” I could see more decision-making happening behind it.
When I first saw the scene, I was bewildered by what was happening. The second time, I realized what had happened.
-
29 November 2024 at 10:37 #3934
🙂
-
30 November 2024 at 11:57 #3937Hello,
NO.7
In the statements:
“that there isn’t a time trigger for the ‘I have applied’ form” and “that there is always a time trigger for the other ‘I applied’ form,”
For “I
Hello,NO.7
In the statements:
“that there isn’t a time trigger for the ‘I have applied’ form” and “that there is always a time trigger for the other ‘I applied’ form,”
For “I have applied,” a time trigger doesn’t seem necessary. However, when I tried out “Do some practice!” using the verb “I work / I have worked”, I realized I naturally included since and for with “I have worked” (e.g., since 2022 and for two years). I believe these are correct and could be considered time triggers.
Does this mean the statements at the top apply specifically to “I have applied” but not necessarily to other verbs like work? Or am I misunderstanding the statements?
-
2 December 2024 at 12:09 #3939Hello,
Please disregard my previous post about ‘since’ and ‘for.’ I watched the video again and found that you did mention ‘since’ and ‘for’ being used
Hello,Please disregard my previous post about ‘since’ and ‘for.’ I watched the video again and found that you did mention ‘since’ and ‘for’ being used with both ‘I have worked’ and ‘I have been working’ sentences.
-
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.